Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access
Cover Image

An Analysis of the Judicial Review of the Impeachment Procedures in Anambra, Oyo, and Plateau in Nigeria’s Fourth Republic

Omololu Fagbadebo, Nirmala Dorasamy

Abstract


Background: The Nigeria’s presidentialism recognises the interdependence of the three branches of government: the legislature, the executive and the judiciary, in a system of separated but shared powers. In furtherance of its oversight role, the Constitution grants the legislature the power, through a prescribed procedure, to remove the heads of the executive guilty of gross misconduct while in office. However, some state legislatures removed their governors in violation of the constitutional requirements. This prompted judicial intervention in interpreting the actions of the legislatures vis a vis the constitutional provisions. This paper reviews the intervention of the judiciary in the cases of impeachment of the governors of Anambra, Oyo and plateau States, Nigeria. Materials and Methods: This is a qualitative study with primary and secondary data generated from court judgments, public and archival materials, key informants’ interviews and extant literature. Result: Upon judicial review of the three cases, the judiciary declared the legislative process that led to the removal of the governors unconstitutional and ordered their restoration. However, the decisions of the courts were based on the violation of the constitutional procedures rather than on the merits of the allegations of gross misconduct. The Constitution ousts the jurisdiction of the courts to inquire into the allegations of gross misconduct. The paper discovered that while the judicial review gave reprieve to the governors, the pronouncements were indication that the legislature could rebound and exercise their power according to the set rules. Conclusion: The paper concluded that the breach of the constitutional procedure by the legislature was an indication that the lawmakers were not originally interested in the effective exercise of the oversight power of impeachment to advance accountability. The lawmakers were motivated by the pursuit of self-interest rather than desire for the public good. The indictment of the legislature by the outcomes of judicial review was an indication that the members of the legislature were not independent minded as envisaged by the constitution to make decisions in the interest of the public.


Keywords


Judiciary, Corruption, Accountability, Legislature, Oversight, Impeachment.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Adebanwi, W. & Obadare, E. 2011.’When corruption fights back: Democracy and elite interest in Nigeria's anticorruption war’. The Journal of Modern African Studies, 49, pp. 185-213.

Ahmad, Muhammad. 2014. ‘Nasarawa Impeachment fails as panel dismisses all charges against ‎Governor Al-Makura’. Premium Times, August 5. Available at:

http://www.premiumtimesng.com/news/166065-%E2%80%8Ebreaking-nasarawa-impeachment-fails-as-panel-dismisses-all-charges-against-%E2%80%8Egovernor-al-makura.html Accessed on August 26, 2017.

Alabi, M. O. A. 2010. ‘Quis Custodiet Custodes? Interrogating the Scope and Limits of Legislative Powers in a Nascent Democracy’. In M. O. A. Alabi & W.O. Egbewole eds. Perspectives on the legislature in the government of Nigeria. Tangier, Kingdom of Morocco: African Training and Research Centre in Administration and Development, pp. 271-304

Alabi, M. O. A. 2014. Politics and law: Anatomy of the siamese twins. 153rd Inaugural Lecture, University of Ilorin, Nigeria, November 13.

Ameh, J., Oke, B. & Obasola, K. 2006. ‘Obi gets impeachment notice’. The Punch, October 17.

Apabiekun, F. 2006. ‘Ladoja’s Political Suicide’. Tell magazine, January 23.

Ariye, E. C, Ogbomah, T. O. Ebipre, P and and Eric, D. 2012. ‘How President Obasanjo Undermined Democracy and Good Governance in Nigeria’. Current Research Journal of Social Sciences, 4(3): 222-227.

Bappah, H. Y. 2016. Nigeria’s Military failure aga8inst Boko Haram insurgency. African Security Review 25(2), pp. 146-158.

Candelaria, S. M. 2012. ‘The doctrine of separation of powers through the prism of impeachment: Context issues and lessons learned’. Integrated Bar of the Philippines (IBP) Journal (Special Issue on Impeachment) (March), pp. 21-39

Constitution of the Federa;l Republic of Nigeria, 1999, as amended.

Egbewole, W. O. and Olatunji, O. A. 2012. ‘Justiciability Theory Versus Political Question Doctrine: Challenges of the Nigerian Judiciary in the Determination of Electoral and Other Related Cases’. The Journal Jurisprudence, 14(117), pp.117-150.

Ezeamalu, Ben. 2017 ‘I was impeached for refusing to inflate budget – Peter Obi’ Premium Times, May 30. Available at:

http://www.premiumtimesng.com/news/232584-i-was-impeached-for-refusing-to-inflate-budget-peter-obi.html Accessed on July 29, 2017.

Fagbadebo, OM. 2019. An Overview of Legislative Oversight and Accountability Mechanisms in Nigeria and South Africa. In OM Fagbadebo and FA Ruffin (eds.) Perspectives on the Legislature and the Prospects of Accountability in Nigeria and South Africa. Cham, Switzerland: Springer International Publishing, pp. 19-44.

Fagbadebo, O. M. 2010. ‘Impeachment procedure and judicial intervention in the legislative process in Nigeria’.In M. O. A. Alabi & W.O. Egbewole eds. Perspectives on the legislature in the government of Nigeria. Tangier, Kingdom of Morocco: African training and Research Centre in Administration and Development, pp. 145-168.

Fagbadebo, O. M. 2016. ‘Exploring the Politics of Impeachment in Nigeria’s presidential System: Insights from Selected States in the Fourth Republic, 1999-2007’. A PhD dissertation, University of KwaZulu-Natal, South Africa.

Frickey, P. P. and Smith, S. S. 2000. ‘Judicial review and the Legislative Process: Some Empirical and Normative Aspects of Due Process of Lawmaking. Boat Working Papers in Public Law, Paper 80.

Global Witness. 2010. How British banks are complicit in Nigerian corruption. London: Global Witness Limited.

Ibrahim, Y. 2017. ‘N4.7bn fraud: Court adjourns for ruling on petitions against former Oyo Governor, Ladoja’. Daily Trust, March 1. Available at:

https://dailytrust.com.ng/news/law/n4-7bn-fraud-court-adjourns-for-ruling-on-petitions-against-former-oyo-governor-ladoja/187463.html. Accessed on August 16, 2017.

Johnson, Dayo. 2017. ‘Olanusi: Former Deputy Governor impeached by Assembly, restored by Court. Vanguard, March 30. Available at:

http://www.vanguardngr.com/2017/03/olanusi-former-d-gov-impeached-assembly-restored-court/. Accessed on April 12, 2017.

Kumolu, C. 2013. ‘An Emergency without Emergency Governors’. Vanguard, May 16. Available at:

http://www.vanguardngr.com/2013/05/an-emergency-without-emergency-governors/. Accessed on August 16, 2017.

Lawan, M. 2010. ‘Abuse of powers of impeachment in Nigeria’. Journal of Modern African Studies, 48 (2), pp. 311–338.

Madison, James. 2008. The Federalist Papers: No. 47. 8 Lillian Goldman Law Library. Available at: http://avalon.law.yale.edu/18th_century/fed47.asp Accessed on August 26, 2017.

Nwabueze, B. O. 1985. Nigeria’s presidential constitution, 1979-1983: The second in constitutional democracy. London, Ikeja, New York: Longman.

Obateru, T. 2006. ‘I shared loot with Obasanjo, Mantu –Dariye’. Vanguard, February 9.

Oladimeji, R. 2017. ‘Oyo SSG wrote N4.7bn fraud petition against Ladoja-Witness’. The Punch, March 2. Available at:

http://punchng.com/oyo-ssg-wrote-n4-7bn-fraud-petition-against-ladoja-witness/. Accessed on August 17, 2017.

Oladimeji, R. 2016. ‘N4.7bn fraud: EFCC calls for arrest warrant against Ladoja’. The Punch, November 11. Available at:

http://punchng.com/n4-7bn-fraud-efcc-calls-arrest-warrant-ladoja/. Accessed on August 16, 2017.

Omobowale, A. O. & Olutayo, A. O. 2007.‘Chief Lamidi Adedibu and patronage politics in Nigeria’.Journal of Modern African Studies, 45(3), pp. 425–446.

Oni, M. A. 2013. ‘Judicial Reivew Of Governors’ Ladoja And Obi Impeachment In Nigeria’s Fourth Republic’. Singaporean Journal of Business Economics, and Management Studies, 1(6), 117-131.

Onochie, C. O. and Richards, O. 2018. Dariye gets 14 years Imprisonment for diverting N1.1b state Fiunds. The Guardian, June 13. Available at:

http://guardian.ng/news/dariye-gets-14-years-imprisonment-for-diverting-n1-1b-state-funds [accessed on June 14, 2018].

Osondu, E. 2006. ‘Nigeria: Anambra Drama Continues, 13 Lawmakers Support Obi’. This Day, October 27.

Premium Times. 19/04/2013. ‘Error by Ladoja’s lawyer makes Appeal Court adjourns N4.7bn corruption charge’. Available at:

http://www.premiumtimesng.com/news/130413-error-by-ladojas-lawyermakesappeal-court-adjourn-n4-7bn-corruption-charge.html [accessed on April 20, 2013].

Sahara Reporters, October 16, 20106. ‘Case against Governor Peter Obi of Anambra State’. Available at:

http://saharareporters.com/2006/10/16/case-against-governor-peter-obi-anambra-state. Accessed on August 24, 2017.

Sowore, O. 2006. ‘We won't back down on Peter Obi-Anambra State Speaker Balonwu’. Saharareporters October 19. Available at: http://saharareporters.com/2006/10/19/we-wont-back-down-peter-obi-anambra [accessed on December 12, 2013].

Yusuf, Umar. 2016. ‘Appeal Court quashes ex-Gov Nyako’s impeachment’. Vanguard, February 12. Available at:

http://www.vanguardngr.com/2016/02/appeal-court-quashes-ex-gov-nyakos-impeachment/. Accessed on May 4, 2017.

Cases Cited

Baker v. Carr, 369 US 186, (1962).

Musa v Hamza & 6 others, [1982] 3 NCLR 229 (FCA)

Abaribe v. Abia State House of Assembly, (2002) 14 NWLR (pt.788) 466

Inakoju & 17 ORS v. Adeleke & 3 ORS 2007) 1 S. C., (Pt 1)

Dapianlong v Dariye (2007) 8 NWLR (Pt 1038) 332

Hon. Michael Dapianlong and 5 Others v. Chief (Dr) Joshua Chibi Dariye and Another (2007) 2 All N.L.R. 293

Mike Balonwu v. Mr Peter Obi (2007) 5 NWLR (Pt.1028) 488 C.A


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.